Yes, it’s okay to give thrifted gifts. In ThredUp’s 2026 Holiday Report, a GlobalData survey of 2,123 U.S. adults conducted in September 2026, 62% said they plan to buy secondhand this holiday season.

Finding out a gift was secondhand doesn’t change how most people feel about it. Of those surveyed, 84% said they’d like a gift they already loved the same or more after learning it was secondhand.

So the etiquette question is settled for most of the people on your list, and what’s left is whether the sweater or the glasses in your hands suit the person you’re buying for. Settle that in the aisle.

What Makes a Secondhand Gift Work

A thrifted gift clears the same bar as a new one: it’s in good shape, and it suits the person opening it. Where it came from doesn’t figure into either.

Size is the risky part. Clothing has to fit, and since a thrifted sweater can’t be traded for the next size up, it works best for someone whose size you already know. Books, glassware, and frames fit everyone.

Secondhand Gifts to Look For

Sweaters

The care label is the first thing to read on a sweater. A tag reading wool, cashmere, or alpaca tells you more about how the sweater will hold up than the brand name does.

Then check the spots where knitwear wears out. Look at the underarms, cuffs, and collar for thin patches or holes, and hold the body up to the store lights, where moth holes show up as pinpricks of light. Pilling (the small balls of fiber that form where a sweater rubs against itself) comes off with a fabric shaver. A hole doesn’t.

A sweater with no holes still has to fit the person wearing it, and sizes on older labels don’t always match today’s charts. If you know their size, measure a sweater that fits them across the chest, armpit to armpit, then measure the one on the rack the same way. Value World doesn’t have dressing rooms, but mirrors throughout the store let you hold a sweater up to check the length. If you don’t know their size, buy them a book.

Books

Open a book to the middle before you buy it. The spine should hold without cracking loose, the pages should lie flat (wavy pages mean water got to them), and nothing should slide out when you turn the book over. Pass on anything that fails.

A previous owner’s name inside the cover gives a used book some history. If there’s a personal note written to someone else, pick another copy.

Glassware

Chips hide on the rim of a glass, so run a fingertip around it before the glass goes in your cart. Next, hold the glass up to a light: a cloudy film from hard water washes off with white vinegar, but a white haze that survives rinsing is dishwasher etching, and etching is permanent.

Inventory changes every day, so a complete matching set is hard to count on. That works in your favor. A few cut-glass tumblers picked one at a time, each a little different, look chosen in a way a boxed set doesn’t, and they suit anyone who likes to host.

Frames

With a frame, the photo you put in it is the gift. Check that the corners sit tight, the glass has no cracks or scratches, and the back still has its stand or hanging hardware. If the frame comes with old art inside, the tabs on the backing bend open by hand.

Fill the frame before wrapping. If it takes a standard size like 5×7 or 8×10, any photo service can print a picture to fit, and a photo of the person opening the gift is the obvious pick.

When the Person on Your List Prefers

Some people on your list will want something new. Purple tags cover that group of people. At Value World, purple-tagged items are new merchandise from name-brand retailers, sold for a fraction of their original retail price.

Before You Wrap It

At most thrift stores, everything is final sale. That means that the person opening your gift can’t swap a sweater for a different size or trade in a book they already own, so the store is the last place anyone can check the gift. Inspect it there.

Clean everything before it goes in a box. Wash or dry-clean clothing according to the care label, and run glassware through hot, soapy water. If a price sticker won’t come off a book jacket or a frame cleanly, a few seconds under a hair dryer on low softens the adhesive.

Then, if you feel it would be best for the individual to know, feel free to tell them it’s thrifted. Out loud, on purpose. A gift you picked off the rack, checked by hand, and washed before wrapping took more work than one that showed up in a shipping box, and saying where it came from is part of giving it.

Plan for More than One Trip

Associates put out new items on the sales floor constantly, so the racks you shop this week won’t look like the racks you shop next week. Gift shopping at a thrift store works better as a handful of visits than as one trip the weekend before the holidays. When the right sweater shows up, buy it. It won’t wait.

Discounts rotate too. Each store posts its own Color of the Day, and items with that tag color are 50% off. On Sundays, a selection of white-tag items goes 50% off, and those items stay on the sales floor through the following Saturday. Our guide to thrift store shopping for beginners covers the full color tag system.

The VIP Club is free. Every dollar you spend in the store earns one point, 100 points gets you $5 off, and 150 points gets you $10 off. Points last 24 months.

Members get early notice of sale locations, including the Magical Mystery Sale, when select stores go 50% off and the location changes each week.

Join the VIP Club before your first gift run, and make that run this week. Starting now leaves room for several more trips before the holidays.

Find a store

Value World has stores in the Cleveland, Detroit, and Houston areas. Find your nearest one on the Ohio, Michigan, or Texas locations page. Stores are open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 9 PM and Sunday from 12 PM to 6 PM. Holiday hours vary.

FAQs

Is it rude to give a thrifted gift?

No. What comes across as careless is a gift in rough condition or one that doesn’t suit the person, but that holds true for new gifts too. A secondhand sweater with no holes, washed and wrapped, looks like any other present on the table.

Would people rather get a secondhand gift than a new one?

More than half would, if it’s one of a kind. In ThredUp’s 2026 Holiday Report, 55% said they’d rather receive a one-of-a-kind, vintage, or hard-to-find secondhand gift in excellent condition than a brand-new, mass-produced version.

Can I return a gift bought at Value World?

No. All sales are final, including purple-tag new items, and there are no exchanges. Check size and condition in the store before you buy, and use the mirrors to hold clothing up for length.

Share